Q: Was Sydney Mills convicted?

Yes . Mills pleaded guilty on June 15, 2026 to second-degree criminal sexual act, a felony, and admitted in open court that he committed the offense in 2022 while employed as a Saugerties police officer. He was sentenced on September 2, 2026 to five years in state prison and ten years of post-release supervision, and he will be required to register as a sex offender.

Q: The criminal case is over. Is it too late to do anything?

No . A criminal case and a civil case are separate. The criminal case was brought by the district attorney on behalf of the state, and it has now concluded. A civil claim is brought by the survivor, and it is the only process that can result in compensation. The end of the criminal case does not close the civil door.

Q: What does it cost to speak with PCVA?

Nothing . The consultation is free and confidential, and there is no obligation to move forward.

Question 1

Was Sydney Mills convicted?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Mills pleaded guilty on June 15, 2026 to second-degree criminal sexual act, a felony, and admitted in open court that he committed the offense in 2022 while employed as a Saugerties police officer. He was sentenced on September 2, 2026 to five years in state prison and ten years of post-release supervision, and he will be required to register as a sex offender.

Question 2

The criminal case is over. Is it too late to do anything?

Accepted Answer

No. A criminal case and a civil case are separate. The criminal case was brought by the district attorney on behalf of the state, and it has now concluded. A civil claim is brought by the survivor, and it is the only process that can result in compensation. The end of the criminal case does not close the civil door.

Question 3

Does his guilty plea help a civil case?

Accepted Answer

It generally does. In many abuse cases, the central dispute is whether the conduct happened at all. Here, Mills admitted it under oath in open court. That admission is part of the public record.

Question 4

Can the Saugerties Police Department or the Town of Saugerties be held responsible?

Accepted Answer

That depends on the facts, and it is one of the main questions PCVA is investigating. When an officer uses the access, credibility, and authority that come with a badge to harm a child, the law asks whether the employing agency knew or should have known of a risk, and whether its hiring, supervision, and complaint-handling practices met the required standard. Those questions are answered through civil discovery, which is a process the criminal case never triggered.

Question 5

How long do I have to file?

Accepted Answer

New York gives survivors of childhood sexual abuse a much longer window than most other claims allow. The precise deadline depends on your age, the dates involved, and whether a public entity is a defendant, and claims against a municipality can carry additional procedural requirements. This is the single most important thing to have checked early. Do not assume your case is too old, and do not assume you have unlimited time.

Question 6

What if I never reported it to anyone?

Accepted Answer

Most survivors do not report at the time, and delayed disclosure is expected rather than unusual, particularly when the person responsible held authority or made threats. Not having reported does not prevent you from bringing a claim.

Question 7

What if I am not certain that what happened qualifies?

Accepted Answer

You do not need to be certain, and you do not need to have decided anything. Part of what a consultation is for is answering that question. If we do not think there is a claim, we will tell you.

Question 8

Will my name become public?

Accepted Answer

Your conversation with PCVA is confidential, and speaking with us does not commit you to filing anything. If a case is eventually filed, courts sometimes permit survivors of sexual abuse to proceed anonymously or under initials, though that is decided case by case. We will explain how it would work in your situation before any decision is made, and nothing gets filed without your agreement.

Question 9

What can a civil claim actually provide?

Accepted Answer

Civil claims can seek compensation for counseling and mental health treatment, medical costs, lost educational or professional opportunity, and the long-term effects of the abuse. They can also compel an institution to produce records and answer questions under oath about what it knew.

Question 10

What does it cost to speak with PCVA?

Accepted Answer

Nothing. The consultation is free and confidential, and there is no obligation to move forward.

Question 11

What if the person who harmed me was someone else connected to Saugerties?

Accepted Answer

We want to hear from you. The investigation into Mills also surfaced abuse by a former Saugerties High School wrestling coach, who pleaded guilty in January 2026 and is now serving a state prison sentence. Abuse in one institution often points to gaps in another. If you were harmed by someone else in a position of trust in the Saugerties area, reach out and we will talk through it.

Construction Site Accidents

Consumer Protection

Insurance Bad Faith

Medical Malpractice

Natural Disasters

Post-trial and Appellate

Product Liability

Personal Injury

Sexual Abuse Survivors

Trucking and Automobile Accidents

Workplace Injuries

Wrongful Death

Sexual Abuse

Protected: Were You or Your Child Abused by Former Saugerties Police Officer Sydney Mills?

Password Protected

Was Your Child Abused by Eric Cato at KIPP Washington Heights Middle School?

David Sibley Abuse Allegations: Meadowdale Elementary Investigation

PCVA Law Files Five New Sexual Abuse Lawsuits Against Kaiser and Northwest Permanente Over Pediatrician Dr. Michael Wilmington

PCVA Law Files Suit Against Optum Medical Care and Prohealth Over Dr. Mark Hoffman Abuse Allegations

Dr. Mark Hoffman Abuse Investigation: Information for Patients and Families

Brookdale Hospital Nurse Sexual Abuse | Kuriakose Poulose

Student-on-Student Sexual Abuse

Dr. Gordon Pyne Abuse Lawsuit: Information for Former Patients and Families

Dr. Michael Wilmington Abuse Investigation: Information for Former Patients and Families

Recent Posts

Discover Your Rights In A Free, Confidential Consultation

Our Locations

Toll Free

SEATTLE OFFICE

Tacoma Office

NEW YORK OFFICE

LOS ANGELES OFFICE