A New York judge has ordered the unsealing of confidential priest personnel files in the Brooklyn Diocese – a landmark decision secured by PCVA Law and a major victory for survivors of clergy sexual abuse. As first reported by NBC New York, the ruling compels the Diocese to disclose decades-old internal records detailing abuse allegations, internal investigations, and what Church officials knew about accused priests. PCVA Law partner Anelga Doumanian was interviewed by NBC regarding the significance of the decision, underscoring that transparency is essential for survivors seeking justice. For years, the Diocese fought to keep these files sealed. The court’s order makes clear that institutions cannot shield evidence of abuse behind claims of confidentiality.
The timing of this ruling is especially significant as it raises serious questions about the Diocese’s stated commitment to helping survivors. The Diocese recently announced that it intends to mediate and resolve approximately 1,100 sexual abuse claims filed under New York’s Child Victims Act but continues to withhold records detailing abuse allegations involving its other priests in other cases.
Truth and accountability begin with transparency, and PCVA Law remains committed to ensuring that survivors receive just that. This landmark ruling represents a critical step toward exposing what happened, who knew, and how Church officials responded.
- New York Times (Feb 02, 2026) – Brooklyn Diocese Agrees to Mediation to Settle Over 1,000 Abuse Claims
- NY 1 (Feb 13, 2026) – Brooklyn Diocese seeks settlement of 1,100 sex abuse claims
- NBC New York (Feb 18, 2026) – New York judge unseals priest personnel files in Brooklyn Diocese
- EWTN New (Feb 20, 2026) Brooklyn Diocese knew of abuse allegations decades before barring priest from ministry, files show